Thursday, November 17, 2011

Why Isn't NASA Hunting For Life?

Even the most ardent fans of the Red Planet must occasionally wish for more than just hints of water popping up in ever-new places. So why not send a robot to hunt directly for little green men? One word: Viking. NASA's Viking landers did just that in 1976, laying out a tasty solution of nutrients to attract any microbes that might be living in a soil sample, like cookies left on a plate for Santa. The nutrients were laced with radioactive carbon, so if the solution was digested, a radiation monitor above the sample would detect the resulting gas. Intriguingly, radioactive carbon was detected, but then another experiment found no evidence of organic compounds in the soil - there were no alien bodies.
"They were hoping to find signs of life but the results came back basically negative - there is no life as we know it," says Ralph Milliken at the University of Notre Dame in Indiana. The US did not send another mission to Mars for 20 years. The $2.5 billion Curiosity rover will hunt for organic molecules and isotopic hints of life, but NASA is still shying away from the L word. "NASA cannot say to taxpayers that they put $2.5 to $3 billion to search for life, and then say, 'We have found no life - thank you, bye bye',' says Michel Cabane, leader of one of Curiosity's organics-sniffing instruments, who is based at the Pierre and Marie Curie University in Paris, France.
"If you project the message that you are hunting for life, even though it is very important to many of us, and you return with a null or ambiguous answer, people would be disappointed," says jack Mustard of Brown University in Providence, Rhode Island, who is a former chair of NASA's advisory panel on Mars. In any case, he and others say the problem may simply be too hard to solve. "If I posed the  question 'prove that life existed in Earth's past' to you, it would be tough," Mustard says. "Geologists would say, we'll go find a fossil. But bodies are not always preserved on Earth."
He points out that Curiosity and other missions that touch down on the planet are only exploring a limited region for a limited time. Bethany Ehlmann at the California Institute of Technology in Pasadena agrees. "Think locally, not globally - that's a slight perversion of what the environmental movement thinks we should do here on Earth;' she says. Curiosity's landing site may once have been a lake, but other intriguing sites suggest life might have found a refuge in hydrothermal springs below the surface. "Environments during the first billion years of Mars history varied substantially," she says. "Now that we know there's this diversity out there, it becomes harder to say that the evidence says 'Mars did not have life'."

SOURCE : NEW SCIENTIST MAGAZINE NOVEMBER 2011

Wednesday, November 16, 2011

Science Now Makes It Possible To Attribute Some Types Of Weather Event To Climate Change

In the aftermath of hurricane Katrina in 2005, a vigorous debate raged as to whether it was a "normal " natural disaster or a consequence of global warming. Al Gore depicted the devastation of New Orleans in his movie An Inconvenient Truth and linked it to climate change. I became involved during a case before the High Court in London challenging a UK government decision to distribute the movie to schools. I was asked to provide expert written evidence on the extent to which the film correctly represented scientific understanding at the time.
I liked the film and thought that Gore's presentation of the causes and likely effects of climate change was broadly accurate. As the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) concluded in its most recent assessment report: "warming of the climate system is unequivocal, as is now evident from observations of increases in global average air and ocean temperatures, widespread melting of snow and ice, and rising global average sea level". And as data continues to pile up, the evidence gets ever stronger that human-induced emissions of greenhouse gases are the main cause of the observed warming over the past century.
But hurricanes are difficult. Climate models predict that they will become more intense. At the same time, considerable uncertainty remains. We only have about 40 years of reliable observational records, which precludes a clear determination of their variability. Given that different aspects of climate change could act to increase or decrease hurricane activity, whether or not Katrina can be ascribed to global warming is a challenge beset by difficulty.
 It is not surprising, then, that in the aftermath of Katrina many scientists were reluctant to make definitive statements about its links with climate change. The same has happened after many other extreme weather events such as floods and droughts. When pressed, scientists often say that instances of extreme weather are consistent with the expected effects of climate change. But such statements are problematic. They can be misinterpreted to imply that every extreme flood or drought is due to climate change when this is manifestly not the case. And when events occur that climate change might make less likely, such as the 1 record-breaking cold snap in the UK last December, it doesn't follow that climate predictions are inconsistent or wrong.
A clearer way of thinking about weather and climate is to consider the odds. After the European heat wave of 2003,1 worked with Myles Allen and Daithi Stone of the University of Oxford to show that human influence had very likely more than doubled the probability of such extreme temperatures. Since then, the concept that human influence could have "loaded the dice" in favour, or against, the occurrence of a particular heatwave, flood or drought has become widely accepted by scientists and seems a relatively straightforward message to communicate to the public. But this doesn't mean that we are yet able to reliably quantify the changed odds of all extreme weather events.
What we need is an attribution system, operated regularly like the weather forecast and made available to the public. Its purpose would be to deliver rapid and authoritative assessments of the links, if any, between recent extreme weather events and human-induced climate change. In the event of, say, a severe flood, the system would provide estimates of the extent to which the event was made more or less likely by human-induced climate change. It would also take into account alternative natural explanations such as the El Nino Southern Oscillation, a large-scale climate pattern in the tropical Pacific Ocean that affects weather worldwide.
We expect such a service would be of great interest to anyone who wants to know whether a given event could be attributed to climate change, from politicians and journalists to homeowners and insurance companies. Are we capable of delivering? Attribution is difficult and it will be important not to undermine the credibility of a system by prematurely attributing events. However, climate science has advanced to the point where it is possible to assess some types of weather event. For example, the European heatwave of 2003 was consistent with an increased risk of extreme weather caused by climate change, whereas the cold US temperatures of 2008 were not — instead being linked to the La Nina phase of the El Nino.
For other events, such as hurricane Katrina and last year's devastating Pakistan floods and Moscow heatwave, the cause remains uncertain. But the development of an attribution system should help drive further improvements in the forecasting models by continually confronting real world examples of extreme weather.
We at the Met Office — the UK's national weather service — are keen to take this idea forward, and have begun to put together an international collaboration of scientists called the Attribution of Climate-related Events Initiative, or ACE for short. Our aim is to understand when we can reliably estimate the odds of particular types of extreme weather event and for which types of events further improvements are required. We hope to have a prototype attribution system up and running in two years.
Should another category five hurricane make landfall on the US mainland its attribution will be tough. But scientific understanding is developing all the time. Were an attribution system established and its strengths and limitations well understood, a future judge, journalist or local resident, interested in who — or indeed what — to blame, would know where to go.
SOURCE : Peter A. Stott - NEW SCIENTIST MAGAZINE NOVEMBER 2011

Sex Is Primitive Interaction

THERE'S no way sex could ever be considered a good solution for reproduction among organisms like us - eukaryotes with complex information contained within membraned cells. After all, the exponential growth of a population reproducing asexually seriously outcompetes any sexual strategy: it doubles with each generation, while a sexual population has to bear the cost of males.
Most of the supposed advantages of sexual strategies stem from the idea that sexual reproduction enlarges the genetic variation in the lineages on which it operates. Mutation-based models argue that sexual reproduction reduces mutations, which suggests the recombination of DNA during the process exists to prevent detrimental changes in offspring. As a result, sexual reproduction could be beneficial by generating offspring with a lower genetic load - a number measuring the extent to which the average individual in a population is inferior to the best possible kind of individual - when there is a high rate of bad mutation.
The special cell division of sexual reproduction - meiosis, which produces haploid gametes which have half as many chromosomes-was first seen as a sort of DNA-repair process for eukaryotes. Thus, each strand of the original double-stranded DNA molecule served as a template for the replication of a new, complementary DNA molecule, allowing damaged DNA to be repaired. In this hypothesis, genetic recombination is seen as a response to the "noise" occurring when genetic information is transmitted. One chromosome can duplicate information from another, and use it to recover any lost genetic information. Even so, this mechanism requires that recombination leads to a repair process that should be faster than the rate of natural damage. Further, recombination repair systems exist in both prokaryotes and eukaryotes, but sexual meiosis is limited to eukaryotes, suggesting that the DNA repair hypothesis is not sufficient to explain the advantage of sexual reproduction.
Then there is the Red Queen hypothesis, named after the scene in Lewis Carroll's Through the Looking-Gloss in which the Red Queen says: "It takes all the running you can do to keep in the same place." This hypothesis aims to explain the advantage of sexual reproduction at the individual level, and the evolutionary arms race between competing species. Sexual reproduction generates a wide diversity of progeny, helping the species survive disease outbreaks, while cloning results in similar genomes between descendants, making the population vulnerable. The diversity resulting from sexual reproduction also allows sexual species to co-evolve with pathogens.
Such hypotheses face major obstacles, however. First, if sex increases the anti-parasite advantage in sexual lineages, sexual species should diversify more often than asexual populations. In fact, asexual groups do not diversify less than sexual species, as shown by rotifers, a diverse group of tiny aquatic organisms. Then there is the problem of origins. Studies of worm species that reproduce asexually have revealed their hybrid origins, with sexual reproduction as their likely ancestral state.
 Another obstacle is that sex is expected to confer selective advantages over generations. But the correlation is poor between the conditions selecting sexual reproduction and viability of future offspring and those favouring recombination — and Red Queen models cannot be used to infer the advantage of sex over the long-term. Plus the results from experiments are by no means straightforward: sexual recombination disrupts favourable gene combinations more often than it generates them — and some clonal species do have great adaptive potential.
So, how should we understand the evolution of sex? Enter my libertine bubble theory, which argues that rather than providing reproductive advantages, it might be better to see sex as a genetic exchange between two organisms, as originating from an archaic horizontal gene transfer process among the prebiotic bubbles on the ocean surface, which are thought to have played a major role in the creation of living cells. My theory suggests sex results from three key primitive conditions: first, bubbles form spontaneously, creating a favourable environment for genetic material; second, the "promiscuous" nature of these bubbles allows transfer of genetic material among the most "libertine" of the bubbles, gradually leading to a certain membrane selectivity; and third, DNA overcrowding encourages primitive meiotic recombination.
These bubbles did indeed form — and start to exchange material. Since interactions involving the exchange of genetic material could be a mechanism through which a self-promoting element spreads genetic information, bubbles practicing gene exchange were advantaged as genetic renewal favours adaptive variation.
Genetic drift meant that the bubbles would have become progressively different. The porosity of proto-cell membranes in contact with other proto-cell membranes would be selected for as long as the process allowed the exchange and possible replication of compatible genetic material. Presumably these exchanges would result in an increasing imbalance in the genetic content among bubbles, with some bubbles losing many genes while others had too many.
 Now, meiosis and haplo-diploid cycles are basic processes that appeared early in evolution. And the fact that such interactions became stable appears to have been enough to make the primitive "sexual" relations efficient at selecting the most libertine bubbles. The asymmetric nature of "female" meiosis, selecting one of four haploid genetic elements for its own benefit while the other three degenerate (in the "male" the four are conserved), resulted in a runaway process.
The last link in the chain is that sex and meiotic recombination in eukaryotes is known to be induced by stressful conditions. In bad conditions, genetic exchanges could renew the proteins in metabolic reactions so interactions among the most libertine proto-cells would be mutually advantageous. And genetic exchanges could increase the rate at which proto-eukaryotes segregate new adaptive mutations, promoting sex.
During their evolutionary history, the efficiency of sexual exchanges was enhanced by the formation of haploid gametes, but a dissymmetry between sperm and ova was also the basis for sexual conflict. The ability to produce numerous sperm means males can mate with many partners, passing genes to many offspring. Females, by contrast, cannot obtain more offspring by so doing; instead, exercising a selective preference for a specific male may increase their reproductive success. ; Sexual conflict is now recognised to drive the attempted manipulation of the sexes. The antagonistic co-evolution generated by sexual .1, conflict may be a reasonable explanation for why so many asexual animals originated from sexual species. The genetic divergence of parental genomes could be large enough to drastically lessen fertility in hybrids and to lead to asexual forms of reproduction.
My theory remains parsimonious: DNA should pass through proto-membranes as they touch and fuel an asymmetric exchange between proto-cells. Bubbles with membrane proteins or favourable mechanisms for exchanging genes would tend to interact more than other bubbles, providing the former with the potential to evolve. The most libertine bubbles — those practising genetic exchanges — would be advantaged because genetic renewal promotes adaptive variation. Focusing on primitive interactions, selection pressures may have led to the emergence of a sexual process in the primitive stages of proto-cell evolution. Rather than competition between proto-eukaryotic bubbles, self-stabilising exchanges of genetic material would increase and enhance their efficiency. All of which is why sex is best seen, not as a solution for reproduction, but as a primitive interaction.

SOURCE : NEW SCIENTIST NOVEMBER 2011

Tuesday, November 15, 2011

LIFE To Blast Off For Mars Moon Phobos

A RAGTAG group of rugged travellers is sent on a three-year round trip to a desolate moon that might he the site of a future human outpost in space. No, that's not a pitch for a reality show - it's a description of an experiment called LIFE (Living Interplanetary Flight Experiment) that is scheduled to set off for the larger of Mars's two moons, Phobos, on 8 November, from Baikonur, Kazakhstan.
The travellers are not celebrities, but some of Earth's toughest organisms, including the bacterium Deinococcus racifodunins and water bears - tiny invertebrates that can survive extreme temperatures and low Earth orbit. The brainchild of the non-profit Planetary Society of Pasadena, California, LIFE will pack to such hardy organisms inside a container the size of a hockey puck and then hitch a ride aboard Russia's Phobos-Grunt (Phobos-Soil) spacecraft.
LIFE will test an idea called transpermia, in which organisms "could be ejected off one planet in impacts, travel through space inside rocks, then be deposited on another world", says Bruce Betts, LIFE's lead scientist.
 Phobos-Grunt "will act as a simulated rock carrying life between planets". If the organisms survive, it would strengthen the idea that life on Earth might have come from other planets, or has travelled to other planets. Phobos lies far beyond Earth's protective magnetosphere, so LIFE should provide a glimpse of what happens when organisms are not shielded from many of the damaging charged particles from the sun and other galactic sources.
While organisms taken lo the moon on Apollo missions went beyond the magnetosphere, it wa: only for a few days at a time. LIFE should expose its organisms to the radiation and temperatures of space for three years, Iike a reality show, LIFE has stirred up controversy. "What happens if the mission crashes and the microbes are allowed to get loose?" asks Rocco Mancinelli, an astrobiologist at the Bay Area Environmental Research institute in Moffett Field, California.
 "Then you have potentially ruined your chances for looking at the origin of organic material or potentially life forms" on Phobos, he says. And what of Mars? Fortunately, the risk of contaminating the Red Planet is extremely slim, says Catharine Conley, NASA's planetary protection officer, who is charged with ensuring agency projects do not contaminate oche) solar system bodies.
To cause contamination, Pascal Lee of the Mars Institute, also in Molten Field, points out that the LIFE capsule would have to miss Phobos, survive the fiery entry into Mars's atmosphere and open up on the surface. Any organisms still living would have to survive the barrage of ultraviolet solar radiation. In desiccated, inactive states, they would not be able to reproduce.
But LIFE isn't the only interesting thing about Phobos-Grunt. Assuming the spacecraft lands on the moon in February 2013, as planned, it will scoop up about 100 grams of soil to bring back to Earth in August 2014- the first material to be brought back from a moon other than our own. The samples could help to settle a burning question - are Mars's two moons, Phobos and Deimos, captured asteroids, leftover building Hocks of Mars, or something else entirely? The samples may even contain dust from Mars itself that was blasted up during an impact.

SOURCE : NEW SCIENTIST MAGAZINE NOVEMBER 2011

Single-Molucule Car Goes for Spin

The tiniest car in the world has gone for a drive. Made of a single molecule, the "vehicle" has four wheel-like paddles that rotate in the same direction when zapped with a beam of electrons.
"The molecule is autonomous," says Syuzanna Harutyunyan, a chemist at the University of Groningen in the Netherlands who worked on the mini motor vehicle. "You don't need to touch it. Just give it energy and it's capable of converting that energy into movement."
To create the nanocar, Harutyunyan and her team designed a molecule with a long central body and one pivoted paddle at each of four corners. The paddles are free to swing around in circles, not unlike wheels.
Ordinarily they arrange themselves so as to minimise crowding with the central body, as this costs the molecule the least amount of energy. But when the team applies a pulse of electrons to the "wheels", some gain energy and move a quarter turn.
In this new position, the wheels experience overcrowding against the body of the nanocar and will move to a more spacious position as soon as possible. They get this opportunity when the bonds holding the wheels to the body stretch, prompting the wheels to move another quarter turn in the same direction, to a more "comfortable" position.
Frigid temperatures of 7 kelvin (-266 °C) help this clunky forward motion by effectively freezing the wheels in place except when excited by the electron pulse and during their subsequent self-adjustment. This keeps them from rolling backwards.
A nanocar had been built before but its wheels only spun in place, equivalent to placing a car on blocks to test it. By contrast, the new vehicle moves in a straight line (Nature, DOI: 10.1038). It's a slow road trip: it takes 10 pulses of electric fuel to move the vehicle 6 nanometres. The head of a pin is about a million nanometres wide.
Nonetheless, nanocar team member Karl-Heinz Ernst at the University of Zurich, Switzerland, is anxious to put it to work. "We have a locomotive," he says, but it's time to put some cars at the back and pull them along." Paul Weiss at the University of California, Los Angeles, says the car can help us unravel why tiny motors in nature, such as the motor proteins that move material around in cells, are so highly efficient. "The reason we work at these small scales is so that we can really understand the motion and efficient energy conversion." He hopes this will lead to more efficient large-scale motors.

SOURCE : NEW SCIENTIST NOVEMBER 2011

New Era in Aviation

ON 1 NOVEMBER the first aircraft with a pressurised fuselage and wings made from carbon-fibre reinforced plastic (CFRP) flew its first passengers from Tokyo to Hiroshima. The All Nippon Airways Boeing 787's composite structure makes it around 15 per cent lighter than a typical aluminium-based plane of that size, increasing fuel efficiency and making aviation greener.
But the media hoopla over the flight disguised some worrying questions about the long-term safety of composite aircraft. On 20 October, the US Government Accountability Office (GAO) published a report which, while accepting that the 787 has been certified as airworthy, questions the ability of the US regulator, the Federal Aviation Administration, to ensure that inspectors are capable of assessing and repairing damage to composite structures over the long life of a plane.
"It is too early to fully assess the adequacy of FAA and industry efforts to address safety-related concerns and to build sufficient capacity to handle composite maintenance and repair: says the GAO.
Until now, only smaller, isolated pieces of secondary structure, such as tail fins and wing leading edges, have been made from composites. The GAO reviewed the scientific literature and interviewed engineers about the evidence underpinning the expansion of composite use to incorporate the whole fuselage. On damage and ageing issues it found the science wanting.
The GAO found that engineers don't know how such materials will behave when damaged, what such damage will look like, and how these factors change as the material ages. Because composite damage is hard to detect - indeed it can be effectively invisible - working out what risk a dent poses is difficult. Too few inspectors are being trained to diagnose such damage, the GAO report adds.
Boeing has no doubts. "We test, we analyse and we demonstrate that even in extreme conditions - which may never be experienced in a full life of service - the airplane is safe and durablethe firm said in a statement.
A composite is made by combining multiple layers of carbon fibres with an epoxy resin. It has a higher strength-to-weight ratio than alumin urn and resists corrosion. But it has different fatigue problems: it tends to snap, rather than bend or stretch over time like a metal.
Although the Boeing 787 is deemed safe, the GAO says regulators must focus on assessing composite damage in service. "The long-term ageing behaviour of these composite materials is indeed an unknown;' says Philip Irving, an aviation structures specialist at Cranfield University in the UK. "What is going to happen to these structures, which are often bonded as a single piece, in the 30-year lifetime of an aircraft?" Much is loovvn about metal, he says. "There is almost nothing equivalent published on composite-structure damage, visibility and growth - and the necessary research is still under wEy," he says.
Some of that research is being done by the Commercial Aircraft Composite Repair Committee, says Boeing, an industry-wide effort involving regulators and manufacturers, including Airbus (which is building its own composite fuselage plane, the A350). In the meantime, Irving says ground staff will need to wield one of their most powerful tools to track down damage in composite planes: "Their eyeballs."

SOURCE : NEW SCIENTIST NOVEMBER 2011

Monday, November 14, 2011

Saturn’s Moons Spin Out Moonlets

SATURN’S rings are far from the serene place you might imagine. Instead, they resemble a space beltway where high-speed crashes between icy particles create and destroy snowballs the size of mountains. This constant thrum of activity could explain how moonlets emerge from the rings, and perhaps even show how planets materialise around a star.
“We used to think of the rings as a perfect, placid society where nothing ever happens,” says Larry Esposito of the University of Colorado in Boulder. “Not only is that not the case — there are collisions happening all the time — but the collisions are actually throwing the rings out of equilibrium.”
In 2009, Saturn's rings were aligned nearly edge-on with the sun, and the low angle of sunlight revealed that the famously flat rings are actually bumpy.
Clumps at the edges of the prominent B ring cast dramatic shadows across the icy plane. “People were totally surprised by those images,” Esposito says. “Nobody expected this.” Now Esposito and colleagues think they can explain the clumps, which come together and break up again over periods of hours to months.
Observations made since 2004 using the Cassini spacecraft provided the team with clues. In the B ring, the zoo to 2ooo-metre- — wide clumps appear most often ahead of and behind the moon Mimas, whose passage carves out the ring’s edge. In the more distant F ring, the clumps precede and lag behind the moon it Prometheus.
This suggests that the gravity of the moons triggers the formation of the clumps. Indeed, the team's simulations show that when a moon sweeps by the edge of a ring, its gravity gives the particles in the ring a kick, driving them into one another.
Some stick together, and their gravity attracts more particles towards them, so the clumps keep growing. As a clump grows, its gravity accelerates the surrounding ring particles. And when a clump gets to be about 1 kilometre across, the particles around it are moving so fast their impacts can break up the clump.
The comings and goings of such clumps follow the mathematical rules that describe predator-prey ecology, the team has found (Icarus, DOI: 10.1o16/ j.icarus.2o11.o9.o29). Think of the clumps as a group of rabbits whose population is held in check by the foxes that eat them, says Esposito. When the rabbit population booms, the fox population grows too. But then the foxes overhunt the rabbits, and both populations fall.
Occasionally, a clump could get big enough to retain the bulk of its mass, even after collisions, and become a moon. “Even if only once in a billion collisions do the clumps stick together and survive, those moons could persist for millions of years,” Esposito says.
Saturn's rings are considered to be a laboratory for studying how planets form within the dusty discs around stars. In the same way that Mimas might seed moonlets in Saturn's B ring, a planet like Jupiter could help form smaller planets like Mars, Esposito speculates.

SOURCE : NEW SCIENTIST MAGAZINE NOVEMBER 2011
Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...

 
Design by Free WordPress Themes | Bloggerized by Lasantha - Premium Blogger Themes | Affiliate Network Reviews